REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION

To prepare Pap smears, the routine practice is to fix the slides immediately in 95% ethanol. This study was performed to evaluate the possibility of routine use of alternative method of air-drying and rehydration prior to alcohol fixation instead of conventional method. Paired cervical smears with...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: A. Zare-Mirzaie, K. Khalili-Alam M. Abolhasani
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Tehran University of Medical Sciences 2007-10-01
Series:Acta Medica Iranica
Subjects:
Online Access:https://acta.tums.ac.ir/index.php/acta/article/view/3302
id doaj-b47e375140014aacba5b97e29ef54109
record_format Article
spelling doaj-b47e375140014aacba5b97e29ef541092020-11-25T03:55:02ZengTehran University of Medical SciencesActa Medica Iranica0044-60251735-96942007-10-01455REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION A. Zare-Mirzaie0 K. Khalili-Alam M. Abolhasani1 To prepare Pap smears, the routine practice is to fix the slides immediately in 95% ethanol. This study was performed to evaluate the possibility of routine use of alternative method of air-drying and rehydration prior to alcohol fixation instead of conventional method. Paired cervical smears with at least low cellularity were collected from 117 women who participated in the study. One set was labeled WF (wet fixed or fixed immediately in 95% ethanol) and the other one ARF (air-dried, rehydrated and fixed). The latter further split into 3 subgroups based on the duration of air-drying. The staining quality of the slides was assessed with respect to chromatin, nuclear and cytoplasmic borders, cytolysis, cellularity, cytoplasmic staining, and red blood cells lysis. Then they were graded blindly. The results were analyzed by Chi square test to compare the defined parameters between the 2 groups and also the 3 subgroups. ARF slides were significantly better with regard to clearance of background due to the lysis of red blood cells (P value, 0.000, x2 test; kappa, -0.27). No statistically significant differences were noted between two groups in terms of other cytologic features. Cytologic features of ARF slides were statistically identical to WF smears. However, red blood cells lysis rendered clearer background in ARF slides. Air-drying and rehydration of slides is a superior method for heavily blood stained smears and can be used at least with identical quality for routine practice. https://acta.tums.ac.ir/index.php/acta/article/view/3302Pap smearsrehydrationair-dried
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author A. Zare-Mirzaie
K. Khalili-Alam M. Abolhasani
spellingShingle A. Zare-Mirzaie
K. Khalili-Alam M. Abolhasani
REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
Acta Medica Iranica
Pap smears
rehydration
air-dried
author_facet A. Zare-Mirzaie
K. Khalili-Alam M. Abolhasani
author_sort A. Zare-Mirzaie
title REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
title_short REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
title_full REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
title_fullStr REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
title_full_unstemmed REHYDRATION OF AIR-DRIED CERVICAL SMEARS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO ROUTINE WET FIXATION
title_sort rehydration of air-dried cervical smears: an alternative to routine wet fixation
publisher Tehran University of Medical Sciences
series Acta Medica Iranica
issn 0044-6025
1735-9694
publishDate 2007-10-01
description To prepare Pap smears, the routine practice is to fix the slides immediately in 95% ethanol. This study was performed to evaluate the possibility of routine use of alternative method of air-drying and rehydration prior to alcohol fixation instead of conventional method. Paired cervical smears with at least low cellularity were collected from 117 women who participated in the study. One set was labeled WF (wet fixed or fixed immediately in 95% ethanol) and the other one ARF (air-dried, rehydrated and fixed). The latter further split into 3 subgroups based on the duration of air-drying. The staining quality of the slides was assessed with respect to chromatin, nuclear and cytoplasmic borders, cytolysis, cellularity, cytoplasmic staining, and red blood cells lysis. Then they were graded blindly. The results were analyzed by Chi square test to compare the defined parameters between the 2 groups and also the 3 subgroups. ARF slides were significantly better with regard to clearance of background due to the lysis of red blood cells (P value, 0.000, x2 test; kappa, -0.27). No statistically significant differences were noted between two groups in terms of other cytologic features. Cytologic features of ARF slides were statistically identical to WF smears. However, red blood cells lysis rendered clearer background in ARF slides. Air-drying and rehydration of slides is a superior method for heavily blood stained smears and can be used at least with identical quality for routine practice.
topic Pap smears
rehydration
air-dried
url https://acta.tums.ac.ir/index.php/acta/article/view/3302
work_keys_str_mv AT azaremirzaie rehydrationofairdriedcervicalsmearsanalternativetoroutinewetfixation
AT kkhalilialammabolhasani rehydrationofairdriedcervicalsmearsanalternativetoroutinewetfixation
_version_ 1724471122749030400