Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations

Genetic alterations have recently been described as emerging during the culture of embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent stem cells, raising concerns about their safety in future clinical use. Myoblasts are adult stem cells with important therapeutic potential that have been used in clinical t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Aurélie Bisson, Stéphanie Le Corre, Géraldine Joly-Helas, Pascal Chambon, Laetitia Demoulins, Laetitia Jean, Sahil Adriouch, Laurent Drouot, Camille Giverne, Francis Roussel, Serge Jacquot, Christelle Doucet, Francis Michot, Marek Lamacz, Thierry Frébourg, Jean-Michel Flaman, Olivier Boyer
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SAGE Publishing 2014-12-01
Series:Cell Transplantation
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.3727/096368913X670192
id doaj-bc9ced0632c54c71850396f0dae6c7c0
record_format Article
spelling doaj-bc9ced0632c54c71850396f0dae6c7c02020-11-25T03:24:25ZengSAGE PublishingCell Transplantation0963-68971555-38922014-12-012310.3727/096368913X670192Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast PreparationsAurélie Bisson0Stéphanie Le Corre1Géraldine Joly-Helas2Pascal Chambon3Laetitia Demoulins4Laetitia Jean5Sahil Adriouch6Laurent Drouot7Camille Giverne8Francis Roussel9Serge Jacquot10Christelle Doucet11Francis Michot12Marek Lamacz13Thierry Frébourg14Jean-Michel Flaman15Olivier Boyer16Celogos, Paris, FranceRouen University Hospital, Laboratory of Biotherapy, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Department of Cytogenetics, Rouen, FranceInserm, U1079, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Laboratory of Biotherapy, Rouen, FranceNormandy University, IRIB, Rouen, FranceNormandy University, IRIB, Rouen, FranceNormandy University, IRIB, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Laboratory of Biotherapy, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Department of Pathology, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Laboratory of Biotherapy, Rouen, FranceCelogos, Paris, FranceRouen University Hospital, Department of Digestive Surgery, Rouen, FranceNormandy University, IRIB, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Department of Genetics, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Department of Genetics, Rouen, FranceRouen University Hospital, Laboratory of Biotherapy, Rouen, FranceGenetic alterations have recently been described as emerging during the culture of embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent stem cells, raising concerns about their safety in future clinical use. Myoblasts are adult stem cells with important therapeutic potential that have been used in clinical trials for almost 20 years, but their genome integrity has not yet been established. Here we produced 10 human myoblast preparations and investigated their genomic stability. At the third passage, half of the preparations had a normal karyotype and half showed one to four alterations/30 metaphases. Chromosome 2 trisomy was found in 1–2/30 meta-phases and/or 2/100 nuclei by FISH in 3/10 samples, and there was no other recurrent anomaly. When prolonging cultures, these erratic abnormalities were never associated with a growth advantage. Cellular senescence was manifested in all samples by growth arrest before passage 15. Expression of TERT was always negative. Molecular analysis of individual p53 transcripts did not reveal tumorigenic mutations. CGH array (10 samples) and exome sequencing (one sample) failed to detect copy number variations or accumulation of mutations, respectively. Myoblasts did not grow either in soft agar or in vivo after injection in immunodeficient mice. Hence, occasional genomic abnormalities may occur during myoblast culture but are not associated with risk of transformation.https://doi.org/10.3727/096368913X670192
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Aurélie Bisson
Stéphanie Le Corre
Géraldine Joly-Helas
Pascal Chambon
Laetitia Demoulins
Laetitia Jean
Sahil Adriouch
Laurent Drouot
Camille Giverne
Francis Roussel
Serge Jacquot
Christelle Doucet
Francis Michot
Marek Lamacz
Thierry Frébourg
Jean-Michel Flaman
Olivier Boyer
spellingShingle Aurélie Bisson
Stéphanie Le Corre
Géraldine Joly-Helas
Pascal Chambon
Laetitia Demoulins
Laetitia Jean
Sahil Adriouch
Laurent Drouot
Camille Giverne
Francis Roussel
Serge Jacquot
Christelle Doucet
Francis Michot
Marek Lamacz
Thierry Frébourg
Jean-Michel Flaman
Olivier Boyer
Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
Cell Transplantation
author_facet Aurélie Bisson
Stéphanie Le Corre
Géraldine Joly-Helas
Pascal Chambon
Laetitia Demoulins
Laetitia Jean
Sahil Adriouch
Laurent Drouot
Camille Giverne
Francis Roussel
Serge Jacquot
Christelle Doucet
Francis Michot
Marek Lamacz
Thierry Frébourg
Jean-Michel Flaman
Olivier Boyer
author_sort Aurélie Bisson
title Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
title_short Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
title_full Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
title_fullStr Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
title_full_unstemmed Chromosomal Instability but Lack of Transformation in Human Myoblast Preparations
title_sort chromosomal instability but lack of transformation in human myoblast preparations
publisher SAGE Publishing
series Cell Transplantation
issn 0963-6897
1555-3892
publishDate 2014-12-01
description Genetic alterations have recently been described as emerging during the culture of embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent stem cells, raising concerns about their safety in future clinical use. Myoblasts are adult stem cells with important therapeutic potential that have been used in clinical trials for almost 20 years, but their genome integrity has not yet been established. Here we produced 10 human myoblast preparations and investigated their genomic stability. At the third passage, half of the preparations had a normal karyotype and half showed one to four alterations/30 metaphases. Chromosome 2 trisomy was found in 1–2/30 meta-phases and/or 2/100 nuclei by FISH in 3/10 samples, and there was no other recurrent anomaly. When prolonging cultures, these erratic abnormalities were never associated with a growth advantage. Cellular senescence was manifested in all samples by growth arrest before passage 15. Expression of TERT was always negative. Molecular analysis of individual p53 transcripts did not reveal tumorigenic mutations. CGH array (10 samples) and exome sequencing (one sample) failed to detect copy number variations or accumulation of mutations, respectively. Myoblasts did not grow either in soft agar or in vivo after injection in immunodeficient mice. Hence, occasional genomic abnormalities may occur during myoblast culture but are not associated with risk of transformation.
url https://doi.org/10.3727/096368913X670192
work_keys_str_mv AT aureliebisson chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT stephanielecorre chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT geraldinejolyhelas chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT pascalchambon chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT laetitiademoulins chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT laetitiajean chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT sahiladriouch chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT laurentdrouot chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT camillegiverne chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT francisroussel chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT sergejacquot chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT christelledoucet chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT francismichot chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT mareklamacz chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT thierryfrebourg chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT jeanmichelflaman chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
AT olivierboyer chromosomalinstabilitybutlackoftransformationinhumanmyoblastpreparations
_version_ 1724601591234822144