Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences

The importance of embodiment for effective robot performance has been postulated for a long time. Despite this, only relatively recently concrete quantitative models were put forward to characterize the advantages provided by a well-chosen embodiment. We here use one of these models, based on the co...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Bente Riegler, Daniel Polani, Volker Steuber
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-04-01
Series:Frontiers in Robotics and AI
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.535158/full
id doaj-c197c0769fc347479e3f09081cb48db0
record_format Article
spelling doaj-c197c0769fc347479e3f09081cb48db02021-04-30T14:56:51ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Robotics and AI2296-91442021-04-01810.3389/frobt.2021.535158535158Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted SequencesBente Riegler0Daniel Polani1Volker Steuber2Sepia Lab, Adaptive Systems Group, School of Engineering and Computer Science, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, United KingdomSepia Lab, Adaptive Systems Group, School of Engineering and Computer Science, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, United KingdomBiocomputation Research Group, School of Engineering and Computer Science, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, United KingdomThe importance of embodiment for effective robot performance has been postulated for a long time. Despite this, only relatively recently concrete quantitative models were put forward to characterize the advantages provided by a well-chosen embodiment. We here use one of these models, based on the concept of relevant information, to identify in a minimalistic scenario how and when embodiment affects the decision density. Concretely, we study how embodiment affects information costs when, instead of atomic actions, scripts are introduced, that is, predefined action sequences. Their inclusion can be treated as a straightforward extension of the basic action space. We will demonstrate the effect on informational decision cost of utilizing scripts vs. basic actions using a simple navigation task. Importantly, we will also employ a world with “mislabeled” actions, which we will call a “twisted” world. This is a model which had been used in an earlier study of the influence of embodiment on decision costs. It will turn out that twisted scenarios, as opposed to well-labeled (“embodied”) ones, are significantly more costly in terms of relevant information. This cost is further worsened when the agent is forced to lower the decision density by employing scripts (once a script is triggered, no decisions are taken until the script has run to its end). This adds to our understanding why well-embodied (interpreted in our model as well-labeled) agents should be preferable, in a quantifiable, objective sense.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.535158/fullagent controlinformation theoryembodimentReinforcement learningmorphological computing
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Bente Riegler
Daniel Polani
Volker Steuber
spellingShingle Bente Riegler
Daniel Polani
Volker Steuber
Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
Frontiers in Robotics and AI
agent control
information theory
embodiment
Reinforcement learning
morphological computing
author_facet Bente Riegler
Daniel Polani
Volker Steuber
author_sort Bente Riegler
title Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
title_short Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
title_full Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
title_fullStr Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
title_full_unstemmed Embodiment and Its Influence on Informational Costs of Decision Density—Atomic Actions vs. Scripted Sequences
title_sort embodiment and its influence on informational costs of decision density—atomic actions vs. scripted sequences
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
series Frontiers in Robotics and AI
issn 2296-9144
publishDate 2021-04-01
description The importance of embodiment for effective robot performance has been postulated for a long time. Despite this, only relatively recently concrete quantitative models were put forward to characterize the advantages provided by a well-chosen embodiment. We here use one of these models, based on the concept of relevant information, to identify in a minimalistic scenario how and when embodiment affects the decision density. Concretely, we study how embodiment affects information costs when, instead of atomic actions, scripts are introduced, that is, predefined action sequences. Their inclusion can be treated as a straightforward extension of the basic action space. We will demonstrate the effect on informational decision cost of utilizing scripts vs. basic actions using a simple navigation task. Importantly, we will also employ a world with “mislabeled” actions, which we will call a “twisted” world. This is a model which had been used in an earlier study of the influence of embodiment on decision costs. It will turn out that twisted scenarios, as opposed to well-labeled (“embodied”) ones, are significantly more costly in terms of relevant information. This cost is further worsened when the agent is forced to lower the decision density by employing scripts (once a script is triggered, no decisions are taken until the script has run to its end). This adds to our understanding why well-embodied (interpreted in our model as well-labeled) agents should be preferable, in a quantifiable, objective sense.
topic agent control
information theory
embodiment
Reinforcement learning
morphological computing
url https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frobt.2021.535158/full
work_keys_str_mv AT benteriegler embodimentanditsinfluenceoninformationalcostsofdecisiondensityatomicactionsvsscriptedsequences
AT danielpolani embodimentanditsinfluenceoninformationalcostsofdecisiondensityatomicactionsvsscriptedsequences
AT volkersteuber embodimentanditsinfluenceoninformationalcostsofdecisiondensityatomicactionsvsscriptedsequences
_version_ 1721497775219146752