Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study
Background<br /> Disinvestment from inefficient health services may be a potential solution to rising healthcare costs, but there has been poor uptake of disinvestment recommendations. This Australian study aims to understand how health professionals react when confronted with a plan to disinv...
Main Authors: | , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Kerman University of Medical Sciences
2019-07-01
|
Series: | International Journal of Health Policy and Management |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | https://www.ijhpm.com/article_3610_26797f3fa8a81fc6feb9bb7242d7eb11.pdf |
id |
doaj-d0f4c7a3d54b49bfbd5bd6ad814b5379 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-d0f4c7a3d54b49bfbd5bd6ad814b53792020-11-25T03:27:16ZengKerman University of Medical SciencesInternational Journal of Health Policy and Management2322-59392322-59392019-07-018740341110.15171/ijhpm.2019.203610Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative StudyDeb Mitchell0Lisa O’Brien1Anne Bardoel2Terry Haines3Monash Health Community, Monash Health, Dandenong, VIC, AustraliaOccupational Therapy Department, School of Primary and Allied Health Care, Monash University, Frankston, VIC, AustraliaDepartment of Management and Marketing, Swinburne University of Technology, Hawthorn, VIC, AustraliaSchool of Primary and Allied Health Care, Monash University, Frankston, VIC, AustraliaBackground<br /> Disinvestment from inefficient health services may be a potential solution to rising healthcare costs, but there has been poor uptake of disinvestment recommendations. This Australian study aims to understand how health professionals react when confronted with a plan to disinvest from a health service they previously provided to their patients.<br /> <br /> Methods<br /> This qualitative study took place prior to the disinvestment phase of a trial which removed weekend allied health services from acute hospital wards, to evaluate the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of the service. Observations and focus groups were used to collect data from 156 participants which was analysed thematically.<br /> <br /> Results<br /> Initial reactions to the disinvestment were almost universally negative, with staff extremely concerned about the impact on the safety and quality of patient care and planning ways to circumvent the trial. Removal of existing services was perceived as a loss and created a direct threat to some clinicians’ professional identity. With time, discussion, and understanding of the project’s context, some staff moved towards acceptance and perceived the trial as an opportunity, particularly given the service was to be reinstated after the disinvestment.<br /> <br /> Conclusion<br /> Clinicians and health service managers are protective of the services they deliver and can create barriers to disinvestment. Even when services are removed to ascertain their value, health professionals may continue to provide services to their patients. Measuring the impact of the disinvestment may assist staff to accept the removal of a service.https://www.ijhpm.com/article_3610_26797f3fa8a81fc6feb9bb7242d7eb11.pdfdisinvestmentstaff reactionsweekend allied health servicesservice changehealthcare |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Deb Mitchell Lisa O’Brien Anne Bardoel Terry Haines |
spellingShingle |
Deb Mitchell Lisa O’Brien Anne Bardoel Terry Haines Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study International Journal of Health Policy and Management disinvestment staff reactions weekend allied health services service change healthcare |
author_facet |
Deb Mitchell Lisa O’Brien Anne Bardoel Terry Haines |
author_sort |
Deb Mitchell |
title |
Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study |
title_short |
Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study |
title_full |
Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study |
title_fullStr |
Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study |
title_full_unstemmed |
Understanding Health Professional Responses to Service Disinvestment: A Qualitative Study |
title_sort |
understanding health professional responses to service disinvestment: a qualitative study |
publisher |
Kerman University of Medical Sciences |
series |
International Journal of Health Policy and Management |
issn |
2322-5939 2322-5939 |
publishDate |
2019-07-01 |
description |
Background<br /> Disinvestment from inefficient health services may be a potential solution to rising healthcare costs, but there has been poor uptake of disinvestment recommendations. This Australian study aims to understand how health professionals react when confronted with a plan to disinvest from a health service they previously provided to their patients.<br /> <br /> Methods<br /> This qualitative study took place prior to the disinvestment phase of a trial which removed weekend allied health services from acute hospital wards, to evaluate the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of the service. Observations and focus groups were used to collect data from 156 participants which was analysed thematically.<br /> <br /> Results<br /> Initial reactions to the disinvestment were almost universally negative, with staff extremely concerned about the impact on the safety and quality of patient care and planning ways to circumvent the trial. Removal of existing services was perceived as a loss and created a direct threat to some clinicians’ professional identity. With time, discussion, and understanding of the project’s context, some staff moved towards acceptance and perceived the trial as an opportunity, particularly given the service was to be reinstated after the disinvestment.<br /> <br /> Conclusion<br /> Clinicians and health service managers are protective of the services they deliver and can create barriers to disinvestment. Even when services are removed to ascertain their value, health professionals may continue to provide services to their patients. Measuring the impact of the disinvestment may assist staff to accept the removal of a service. |
topic |
disinvestment staff reactions weekend allied health services service change healthcare |
url |
https://www.ijhpm.com/article_3610_26797f3fa8a81fc6feb9bb7242d7eb11.pdf |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT debmitchell understandinghealthprofessionalresponsestoservicedisinvestmentaqualitativestudy AT lisaobrien understandinghealthprofessionalresponsestoservicedisinvestmentaqualitativestudy AT annebardoel understandinghealthprofessionalresponsestoservicedisinvestmentaqualitativestudy AT terryhaines understandinghealthprofessionalresponsestoservicedisinvestmentaqualitativestudy |
_version_ |
1724588638730190848 |