The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators
Human operators are key determinants of the performance of most production systems, so individual performance is of intrinsic interest when evaluating current and proposed systems for forest operations. Such evaluations can be useful for diverse purposes, for instance, planning, incentive-setting, c...
Main Authors: | , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
University of Zagreb, Faculty of Forestry
2011-01-01
|
Series: | Croatian Journal of Forest Engineering |
Online Access: | https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/108153 |
id |
doaj-d9f35cbca4064c1eac8ef8cd7fad1d5a |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-d9f35cbca4064c1eac8ef8cd7fad1d5a2020-11-25T02:20:17ZengUniversity of Zagreb, Faculty of ForestryCroatian Journal of Forest Engineering1845-57191848-96722011-01-0132250951972654The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester OperatorsThomas Purfürst0Ola Lindroos1Institute of Forest Utilization and Forest Technology Technische Universität Dresden D-01737 Tharandt GERMANYDepartment of Forest Resource Management, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, SE-901 83 Umeå SWEDENHuman operators are key determinants of the performance of most production systems, so individual performance is of intrinsic interest when evaluating current and proposed systems for forest operations. Such evaluations can be useful for diverse purposes, for instance, planning, incentive-setting, control and costing. Hence, various evaluation methods have been developed, all with pros and cons. Here, we compare subjective, short-term ratings of the work-related behavior of 12 harvester operators and their long-term output (harvested volume per unit time), based on observation periods of a few hours and data gathered over two months, respectively. It was found that competent raters can filter the many, interacting behavioral components and translate short-term observations into grades that reflect the operator’s long-term output well (Spearman’s rs > 0.9). Moreover, substantial variations in performance values obtained by both methods were found, probably at least partly attributable to variations in individual performance of both the operators and the raters. We argue that both of the studied methods could be used to adjust population norms (e.g. productivity functions) to the individual’s performance, with sufficient accuracy for normal production purposes (e.g. planning). However, in a scientific context it could be questioned whether the expected uncontrolled variation in operators’ performance is most efficiently minimized by the introduction of uncontrolled variation in rater’s behavior and/or historical data, or if other precautions could be taken to improve the reliability of the data.https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/108153 |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Thomas Purfürst Ola Lindroos |
spellingShingle |
Thomas Purfürst Ola Lindroos The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators Croatian Journal of Forest Engineering |
author_facet |
Thomas Purfürst Ola Lindroos |
author_sort |
Thomas Purfürst |
title |
The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators |
title_short |
The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators |
title_full |
The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators |
title_fullStr |
The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators |
title_full_unstemmed |
The Correlation between Long-Term Productivity and Short-Term Performance Ratings of Harvester Operators |
title_sort |
correlation between long-term productivity and short-term performance ratings of harvester operators |
publisher |
University of Zagreb, Faculty of Forestry |
series |
Croatian Journal of Forest Engineering |
issn |
1845-5719 1848-9672 |
publishDate |
2011-01-01 |
description |
Human operators are key determinants of the performance of most production systems, so individual performance is of intrinsic interest when evaluating current and proposed systems for forest operations. Such evaluations can be useful for diverse purposes, for instance, planning, incentive-setting, control and costing. Hence, various evaluation methods have been developed, all with pros and cons. Here, we compare subjective, short-term ratings of the work-related behavior of 12 harvester operators and their long-term output (harvested volume per unit time), based on observation periods of a few hours and data gathered over two months, respectively. It was found that competent raters can filter the many, interacting behavioral components and translate short-term observations into grades that reflect the operator’s long-term output well (Spearman’s rs > 0.9). Moreover, substantial variations in performance values obtained by both methods were found, probably at least partly attributable to variations in individual performance of both the operators and the raters. We argue that both of the studied methods could be used to adjust population norms (e.g. productivity functions) to the individual’s performance, with sufficient accuracy for normal production purposes (e.g. planning). However, in a scientific context it could be questioned whether the expected uncontrolled variation in operators’ performance is most efficiently minimized by the introduction of uncontrolled variation in rater’s behavior and/or historical data, or if other precautions could be taken to improve the reliability of the data. |
url |
https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/108153 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT thomaspurfurst thecorrelationbetweenlongtermproductivityandshorttermperformanceratingsofharvesteroperators AT olalindroos thecorrelationbetweenlongtermproductivityandshorttermperformanceratingsofharvesteroperators AT thomaspurfurst correlationbetweenlongtermproductivityandshorttermperformanceratingsofharvesteroperators AT olalindroos correlationbetweenlongtermproductivityandshorttermperformanceratingsofharvesteroperators |
_version_ |
1724872308931166208 |