Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.

In 2015, several provinces in Lao People's Democratic Republic (Lao PDR) experienced a vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak. This survey was conducted (i) to evaluate the vaccination coverage in different settings and cohorts using the seroprevalence of anti-poliovirus (PV) antibodies as a surro...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Maude Pauly, Antony P Black, Phonepaseuth Khampanisong, Phonethipsavanh Nouanthong, Judith M Hübschen, Naphavanh Nanthavong, Kong Sayasinh, Prapan Jutavijittum, Bounthome Samountry, Anonh Xeuatvongsa, Sabine Diedrich, Claude P Muller
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2018-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5953481?pdf=render
id doaj-dc47ee97fddb4a44ae2cb170a26a44f3
record_format Article
spelling doaj-dc47ee97fddb4a44ae2cb170a26a44f32020-11-25T01:53:42ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032018-01-01135e019737010.1371/journal.pone.0197370Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.Maude PaulyAntony P BlackPhonepaseuth KhampanisongPhonethipsavanh NouanthongJudith M HübschenNaphavanh NanthavongKong SayasinhPrapan JutavijittumBounthome SamountryAnonh XeuatvongsaSabine DiedrichClaude P MullerIn 2015, several provinces in Lao People's Democratic Republic (Lao PDR) experienced a vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak. This survey was conducted (i) to evaluate the vaccination coverage in different settings and cohorts using the seroprevalence of anti-poliovirus (PV) antibodies as a surrogate measure, and (ii) to explore the usefulness of an ELISA in a country with limited resources and a specific epidemiological setting. IgG antibodies were assessed by ELISA in Lao children (n = 1216) and adults (n = 1228), including blood donors and health care workers. Protective antibody titers against the 3 vaccine serotypes were determined by microneutralization (VNT) in a subset of participants. More than 92% of the children had anti-poliovirus antibodies, regardless of nutritional status or access to health care, highlighting the success of the vaccination outreach activities in the country. In contrast, anti-poliovirus seroprevalence reached only 81.7% in blood donors and 71.9% in health care workers. Participants born before the introduction of poliovirus vaccination in Lao PDR were considerably less likely to be seropositive. These findings align with the epidemiology of the outbreak. Neutralizing antibodies against at least one of the 3 poliovirus serotypes were detected in all children (99/99) and 93/99 had antibodies against all serotypes. Similarly, all health care workers had neutralizing antibodies against at least one and 92/99 against all serotypes. The comparison of both assays shows an acceptable underestimation of vaccine coverage in children by ELISA, but a low sensitivity of the ELISA in the adults. We show that the ELISA is a reasonable alternative to the VNT in particular in vaccinated children, that an improved version should be serotype specific, and that negativity thresholds should be revisited for optimal sensitivity and specificity. Thus, polio-free countries with an uncertain vaccination coverage and limited laboratory capacity, that are at risk of vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreaks or of re-importation of wild poliovirus may benefit from an improved ELISA for cohort studies to evaluate their immunization program in children.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5953481?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Maude Pauly
Antony P Black
Phonepaseuth Khampanisong
Phonethipsavanh Nouanthong
Judith M Hübschen
Naphavanh Nanthavong
Kong Sayasinh
Prapan Jutavijittum
Bounthome Samountry
Anonh Xeuatvongsa
Sabine Diedrich
Claude P Muller
spellingShingle Maude Pauly
Antony P Black
Phonepaseuth Khampanisong
Phonethipsavanh Nouanthong
Judith M Hübschen
Naphavanh Nanthavong
Kong Sayasinh
Prapan Jutavijittum
Bounthome Samountry
Anonh Xeuatvongsa
Sabine Diedrich
Claude P Muller
Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Maude Pauly
Antony P Black
Phonepaseuth Khampanisong
Phonethipsavanh Nouanthong
Judith M Hübschen
Naphavanh Nanthavong
Kong Sayasinh
Prapan Jutavijittum
Bounthome Samountry
Anonh Xeuatvongsa
Sabine Diedrich
Claude P Muller
author_sort Maude Pauly
title Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
title_short Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
title_full Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
title_fullStr Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
title_full_unstemmed Immunity levels to poliovirus in Lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: A retrospective study.
title_sort immunity levels to poliovirus in lao children and adults before the vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak: a retrospective study.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2018-01-01
description In 2015, several provinces in Lao People's Democratic Republic (Lao PDR) experienced a vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreak. This survey was conducted (i) to evaluate the vaccination coverage in different settings and cohorts using the seroprevalence of anti-poliovirus (PV) antibodies as a surrogate measure, and (ii) to explore the usefulness of an ELISA in a country with limited resources and a specific epidemiological setting. IgG antibodies were assessed by ELISA in Lao children (n = 1216) and adults (n = 1228), including blood donors and health care workers. Protective antibody titers against the 3 vaccine serotypes were determined by microneutralization (VNT) in a subset of participants. More than 92% of the children had anti-poliovirus antibodies, regardless of nutritional status or access to health care, highlighting the success of the vaccination outreach activities in the country. In contrast, anti-poliovirus seroprevalence reached only 81.7% in blood donors and 71.9% in health care workers. Participants born before the introduction of poliovirus vaccination in Lao PDR were considerably less likely to be seropositive. These findings align with the epidemiology of the outbreak. Neutralizing antibodies against at least one of the 3 poliovirus serotypes were detected in all children (99/99) and 93/99 had antibodies against all serotypes. Similarly, all health care workers had neutralizing antibodies against at least one and 92/99 against all serotypes. The comparison of both assays shows an acceptable underestimation of vaccine coverage in children by ELISA, but a low sensitivity of the ELISA in the adults. We show that the ELISA is a reasonable alternative to the VNT in particular in vaccinated children, that an improved version should be serotype specific, and that negativity thresholds should be revisited for optimal sensitivity and specificity. Thus, polio-free countries with an uncertain vaccination coverage and limited laboratory capacity, that are at risk of vaccine-derived poliovirus outbreaks or of re-importation of wild poliovirus may benefit from an improved ELISA for cohort studies to evaluate their immunization program in children.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5953481?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT maudepauly immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT antonypblack immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT phonepaseuthkhampanisong immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT phonethipsavanhnouanthong immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT judithmhubschen immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT naphavanhnanthavong immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT kongsayasinh immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT prapanjutavijittum immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT bounthomesamountry immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT anonhxeuatvongsa immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT sabinediedrich immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
AT claudepmuller immunitylevelstopoliovirusinlaochildrenandadultsbeforethevaccinederivedpoliovirusoutbreakaretrospectivestudy
_version_ 1724989570944073728