Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques

In this paper, it was aimed to select a suitable method to extract the dimensional stone to increase dimensional stone quarries efficiency. The usual methods including diamond cutting-wire method, blasting method, plug, and feather method, Katrock expanding material and Fract expanding material have...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Akbar Esmailzadeh, Reza Mikaeil, Golsa Sadegheslam, Ahmad Aryafar, Hojjat Hosseinzadeh Gharehgheshlagh
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Pouyan Press 2018-01-01
Series:Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.jsoftcivil.com/article_53997_12e1f7d8af556801da4a2529bf5dfb42.pdf
id doaj-e4a216657a2d40fa9a9cb5dd6fe9e0a6
record_format Article
spelling doaj-e4a216657a2d40fa9a9cb5dd6fe9e0a62021-03-21T10:33:20ZengPouyan PressJournal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering2588-28722588-28722018-01-012110111610.22115/scce.2018.5399753997Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS TechniquesAkbar Esmailzadeh0Reza Mikaeil1Golsa Sadegheslam2Ahmad Aryafar3Hojjat Hosseinzadeh Gharehgheshlagh4Urmia University of Technology, Urmia, IranUrmia University of Technology, Urmia, IranUrmia University of Technology, Urmia, IranUniversity of Birjand, Birjand, IranUrmia University of Technology, Urmia, IranIn this paper, it was aimed to select a suitable method to extract the dimensional stone to increase dimensional stone quarries efficiency. The usual methods including diamond cutting-wire method, blasting method, plug, and feather method, Katrock expanding material and Fract expanding material have compared using TOPSIS (Technique for Order Performance by Similarity to Ideal Solution) method by respecting to the following criteria: grass income, safety, desirability, reduction of environmental impacts, waste and reduction of extracting time. FDAHP (Fuzzy Delphi Analytic Hierarchy Process) approach was used in determining the degree of importance of the criteria by expert decision makers. Also, those criteria performed the same impacts were not considered. Consequently, the diamond wire saw method was suggested as the most appropriate method to extract the dimensional stones. It was concluded that the extraction of dimensional stone using diamond wire saw is the best method based on the mentioned criterion compared to other methods.http://www.jsoftcivil.com/article_53997_12e1f7d8af556801da4a2529bf5dfb42.pdfmulti-criteria decision makingdimensional stonetopsisfuzzy delphi
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Akbar Esmailzadeh
Reza Mikaeil
Golsa Sadegheslam
Ahmad Aryafar
Hojjat Hosseinzadeh Gharehgheshlagh
spellingShingle Akbar Esmailzadeh
Reza Mikaeil
Golsa Sadegheslam
Ahmad Aryafar
Hojjat Hosseinzadeh Gharehgheshlagh
Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
multi-criteria decision making
dimensional stone
topsis
fuzzy delphi
author_facet Akbar Esmailzadeh
Reza Mikaeil
Golsa Sadegheslam
Ahmad Aryafar
Hojjat Hosseinzadeh Gharehgheshlagh
author_sort Akbar Esmailzadeh
title Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
title_short Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
title_full Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
title_fullStr Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
title_full_unstemmed Selection of an Appropriate Method to Extract the Dimensional Stones Using FDAHP & TOPSIS Techniques
title_sort selection of an appropriate method to extract the dimensional stones using fdahp & topsis techniques
publisher Pouyan Press
series Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
issn 2588-2872
2588-2872
publishDate 2018-01-01
description In this paper, it was aimed to select a suitable method to extract the dimensional stone to increase dimensional stone quarries efficiency. The usual methods including diamond cutting-wire method, blasting method, plug, and feather method, Katrock expanding material and Fract expanding material have compared using TOPSIS (Technique for Order Performance by Similarity to Ideal Solution) method by respecting to the following criteria: grass income, safety, desirability, reduction of environmental impacts, waste and reduction of extracting time. FDAHP (Fuzzy Delphi Analytic Hierarchy Process) approach was used in determining the degree of importance of the criteria by expert decision makers. Also, those criteria performed the same impacts were not considered. Consequently, the diamond wire saw method was suggested as the most appropriate method to extract the dimensional stones. It was concluded that the extraction of dimensional stone using diamond wire saw is the best method based on the mentioned criterion compared to other methods.
topic multi-criteria decision making
dimensional stone
topsis
fuzzy delphi
url http://www.jsoftcivil.com/article_53997_12e1f7d8af556801da4a2529bf5dfb42.pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT akbaresmailzadeh selectionofanappropriatemethodtoextractthedimensionalstonesusingfdahptopsistechniques
AT rezamikaeil selectionofanappropriatemethodtoextractthedimensionalstonesusingfdahptopsistechniques
AT golsasadegheslam selectionofanappropriatemethodtoextractthedimensionalstonesusingfdahptopsistechniques
AT ahmadaryafar selectionofanappropriatemethodtoextractthedimensionalstonesusingfdahptopsistechniques
AT hojjathosseinzadehgharehgheshlagh selectionofanappropriatemethodtoextractthedimensionalstonesusingfdahptopsistechniques
_version_ 1724210995433308160