Reproducibility of neuroimaging analyses across operating systems

• Main Authors: Tristan eGlatard, Lindsay Burke Lewis, Rafael Ferreira da Silva, Reza eAdalat, Natacha eBeck, Claude eLepage, Pierre eRioux, Marc-Etienne eRousseau, Tarek eSherif, Ewa eDeelman, Najmeh eKhalili-Mahani, Alan Charles Evans
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2015-04-01
• Series: Frontiers in Neuroinformatics
• Subjects: FreeSurfer; reproducibility; Operating Systems; fsl; Civet
• Online Access: http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fninf.2015.00012/full

Neuroimaging pipelines are known to generate different results depending on the computing platform where they are compiled and executed. We quantify these differences for brain tissue classification, fMRI analysis, and cortical thickness (CT) extraction, using three of the main neuroimaging packages (FSL, Freesurfer and CIVET) and different versions of GNU/Linux. We also identify some causes of these differences using library and system call interception. We find that these packages use mathematical functions based on single-precision floating-point arithmetic whose implementations in operating systems continue to evolve. While these differences have little or no impact on simple analysis pipelines such as brain extraction and cortical tissue classification, their accumulation creates important differences in longer pipelines such as subcortical tissue classification, fMRI analysis, and cortical thickness extraction. With FSL, most Dice coefficients between subcortical classifications obtained on different operating systems remain above 0.9, but values as low as 0.59 are observed. Independent component analyses (ICA) of fMRI data differ between operating systems in one third of the tested subjects, due to differences in motion correction. With Freesurfer and CIVET, in some brain regions we find an effect of build or operating system on cortical thickness. A first step to correct these reproducibility issues would be to use more precise representations of floating-point numbers in the critical sections of the pipelines. The numerical stability of pipelines should also be reviewed.