COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE
The analysis of existing methods of determining the expert competence coefficient is carried out. Based on the results of the analysis, it is suggested that experts’ evaluation is made on the basis of objective characteristics and also it is suggested to make a group decision with a margin according...
Main Authors: | , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
National Aerospace University «Kharkiv Aviation Institute»
2017-08-01
|
Series: | Авіаційно-космічна техніка та технологія |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://nti.khai.edu/ojs/index.php/aktt/article/view/735 |
id |
doaj-ee7446ce315946d38ec9d2dc6545ff97 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-ee7446ce315946d38ec9d2dc6545ff972020-11-25T02:19:50ZengNational Aerospace University «Kharkiv Aviation Institute»Авіаційно-космічна техніка та технологія1727-73372663-22172017-08-0106103110778COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEEДмитрий Владимирович ДунаевЛеонид Васильевич КривобоковThe analysis of existing methods of determining the expert competence coefficient is carried out. Based on the results of the analysis, it is suggested that experts’ evaluation is made on the basis of objective characteristics and also it is suggested to make a group decision with a margin according to the Harrington desirability function. Approaches are proposed for the components of the expert's competence coefficient that allow taking into account the objective characteristics of each expert – period of familiarity with the problem, the academic degree and position, as well as the number of publications, reports, etc. on the problem. Thus, we get the value of the expert's competence coefficient taking into account his objective characteristics, which will significantly reduce the subjectivity of the experts' evaluation and improve the quality of the expert committee. The proposed group decision made by an expert committee (regarding a problem considered based on the ratio of difference between the sum of competence coefficients of supporter experts and that of dissident experts to the sum of competence coefficients of the experts with a margin according to the Harrington desirability function, which shall be more than 0.8) will allow taking into account the constructive opinions of the dissident experts. This group decision and determination of the expert’s competence coefficient taking into account the objective characteristics of each expert will reduce the influence of human factor, thus ensures more optimal composing of programs for development testing of rocketry items. An example of practical application in comprehensive development testing program (CDTP) of items of the rocket space complex of a proposed group decision made by an expert committee will allow taking into account the constructive opinions of the dissident experts to introduce subclasses in status of qualifications, which take into account the logic of development test the component parts, that contributes to the optimization of CDTP.http://nti.khai.edu/ojs/index.php/aktt/article/view/735комплексна програма експериментального відпрацювання, кваліфікаційний статус, коефіцієнт компетентності експерта, групове рішення, коефіцієнт «ваги» думки експерта, коефіцієнт знайомства з проблемою, коефіцієнт аргументованості, функція бажаності. |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Дмитрий Владимирович Дунаев Леонид Васильевич Кривобоков |
spellingShingle |
Дмитрий Владимирович Дунаев Леонид Васильевич Кривобоков COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE Авіаційно-космічна техніка та технологія комплексна програма експериментального відпрацювання, кваліфікаційний статус, коефіцієнт компетентності експерта, групове рішення, коефіцієнт «ваги» думки експерта, коефіцієнт знайомства з проблемою, коефіцієнт аргументованості, функція бажаності. |
author_facet |
Дмитрий Владимирович Дунаев Леонид Васильевич Кривобоков |
author_sort |
Дмитрий Владимирович Дунаев |
title |
COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE |
title_short |
COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE |
title_full |
COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE |
title_fullStr |
COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE |
title_full_unstemmed |
COMPOSING OF DEVELOPMENT TESTING PROGRAMS FOR ROCKETRY ITEMS TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE GROUP DECISION MADE BY AN EXPERT COMMITTEE |
title_sort |
composing of development testing programs for rocketry items taking into account the group decision made by an expert committee |
publisher |
National Aerospace University «Kharkiv Aviation Institute» |
series |
Авіаційно-космічна техніка та технологія |
issn |
1727-7337 2663-2217 |
publishDate |
2017-08-01 |
description |
The analysis of existing methods of determining the expert competence coefficient is carried out. Based on the results of the analysis, it is suggested that experts’ evaluation is made on the basis of objective characteristics and also it is suggested to make a group decision with a margin according to the Harrington desirability function. Approaches are proposed for the components of the expert's competence coefficient that allow taking into account the objective characteristics of each expert – period of familiarity with the problem, the academic degree and position, as well as the number of publications, reports, etc. on the problem. Thus, we get the value of the expert's competence coefficient taking into account his objective characteristics, which will significantly reduce the subjectivity of the experts' evaluation and improve the quality of the expert committee. The proposed group decision made by an expert committee (regarding a problem considered based on the ratio of difference between the sum of competence coefficients of supporter experts and that of dissident experts to the sum of competence coefficients of the experts with a margin according to the Harrington desirability function, which shall be more than 0.8) will allow taking into account the constructive opinions of the dissident experts. This group decision and determination of the expert’s competence coefficient taking into account the objective characteristics of each expert will reduce the influence of human factor, thus ensures more optimal composing of programs for development testing of rocketry items. An example of practical application in comprehensive development testing program (CDTP) of items of the rocket space complex of a proposed group decision made by an expert committee will allow taking into account the constructive opinions of the dissident experts to introduce subclasses in status of qualifications, which take into account the logic of development test the component parts, that contributes to the optimization of CDTP. |
topic |
комплексна програма експериментального відпрацювання, кваліфікаційний статус, коефіцієнт компетентності експерта, групове рішення, коефіцієнт «ваги» думки експерта, коефіцієнт знайомства з проблемою, коефіцієнт аргументованості, функція бажаності. |
url |
http://nti.khai.edu/ojs/index.php/aktt/article/view/735 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT dmitrijvladimirovičdunaev composingofdevelopmenttestingprogramsforrocketryitemstakingintoaccountthegroupdecisionmadebyanexpertcommittee AT leonidvasilʹevičkrivobokov composingofdevelopmenttestingprogramsforrocketryitemstakingintoaccountthegroupdecisionmadebyanexpertcommittee |
_version_ |
1724874043768700928 |