The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory
Abstract Researchers use a wide range of confidence scales when measuring the relationship between confidence and accuracy in reports from memory, with the highest number usually representing the greatest confidence (e.g., 4-point, 20-point, and 100-point scales). The assumption seems to be that the...
Main Authors: | , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
SpringerOpen
2017-12-01
|
Series: | Cognitive Research |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41235-017-0086-z |
id |
doaj-f80aa29d175c448b82a04475a6cbf8ae |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-f80aa29d175c448b82a04475a6cbf8ae2020-11-24T23:29:37ZengSpringerOpenCognitive Research2365-74642017-12-012111310.1186/s41235-017-0086-zThe range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memoryEylul Tekin0Henry L. Roediger1Psychology Building, Campus Box 1125Washington University in St. LouisAbstract Researchers use a wide range of confidence scales when measuring the relationship between confidence and accuracy in reports from memory, with the highest number usually representing the greatest confidence (e.g., 4-point, 20-point, and 100-point scales). The assumption seems to be that the range of the scale has little bearing on the confidence-accuracy relationship. In two old/new recognition experiments, we directly investigated this assumption using word lists (Experiment 1) and faces (Experiment 2) by employing 4-, 5-, 20-, and 100-point scales. Using confidence-accuracy characteristic (CAC) plots, we asked whether confidence ratings would yield similar CAC plots, indicating comparability in use of the scales. For the comparisons, we divided 100-point and 20-point scales into bins of either four or five and asked, for example, whether confidence ratings of 4, 16–20, and 76–100 would yield similar values. The results show that, for both types of material, the different scales yield similar CAC plots. Notably, when subjects express high confidence, regardless of which scale they use, they are likely to be very accurate (even though they studied 100 words and 50 faces in each list in 2 experiments). The scales seem convertible from one to the other, and choice of scale range probably does not affect research into the relationship between confidence and accuracy. High confidence indicates high accuracy in recognition in the present experiments.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41235-017-0086-zConfidence-accuracy relationshipConfidence scalesMetacognition |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Eylul Tekin Henry L. Roediger |
spellingShingle |
Eylul Tekin Henry L. Roediger The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory Cognitive Research Confidence-accuracy relationship Confidence scales Metacognition |
author_facet |
Eylul Tekin Henry L. Roediger |
author_sort |
Eylul Tekin |
title |
The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
title_short |
The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
title_full |
The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
title_fullStr |
The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
title_full_unstemmed |
The range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
title_sort |
range of confidence scales does not affect the relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory |
publisher |
SpringerOpen |
series |
Cognitive Research |
issn |
2365-7464 |
publishDate |
2017-12-01 |
description |
Abstract Researchers use a wide range of confidence scales when measuring the relationship between confidence and accuracy in reports from memory, with the highest number usually representing the greatest confidence (e.g., 4-point, 20-point, and 100-point scales). The assumption seems to be that the range of the scale has little bearing on the confidence-accuracy relationship. In two old/new recognition experiments, we directly investigated this assumption using word lists (Experiment 1) and faces (Experiment 2) by employing 4-, 5-, 20-, and 100-point scales. Using confidence-accuracy characteristic (CAC) plots, we asked whether confidence ratings would yield similar CAC plots, indicating comparability in use of the scales. For the comparisons, we divided 100-point and 20-point scales into bins of either four or five and asked, for example, whether confidence ratings of 4, 16–20, and 76–100 would yield similar values. The results show that, for both types of material, the different scales yield similar CAC plots. Notably, when subjects express high confidence, regardless of which scale they use, they are likely to be very accurate (even though they studied 100 words and 50 faces in each list in 2 experiments). The scales seem convertible from one to the other, and choice of scale range probably does not affect research into the relationship between confidence and accuracy. High confidence indicates high accuracy in recognition in the present experiments. |
topic |
Confidence-accuracy relationship Confidence scales Metacognition |
url |
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41235-017-0086-z |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT eylultekin therangeofconfidencescalesdoesnotaffecttherelationshipbetweenconfidenceandaccuracyinrecognitionmemory AT henrylroediger therangeofconfidencescalesdoesnotaffecttherelationshipbetweenconfidenceandaccuracyinrecognitionmemory AT eylultekin rangeofconfidencescalesdoesnotaffecttherelationshipbetweenconfidenceandaccuracyinrecognitionmemory AT henrylroediger rangeofconfidencescalesdoesnotaffecttherelationshipbetweenconfidenceandaccuracyinrecognitionmemory |
_version_ |
1725544696570183680 |