Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests

The following short communication article presents a method for comparing the species composition of Estonian forests and parks, giving an overview of the data that is currently being gathered and underlining how these two datasets can be compared. Even though both forest and park invent...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Nele Nutt, Ardo Kubjas, Minea Kaplinski-Sauk
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Estonian Academic Agricultural Society 2020-06-01
Series:Agraarteadus
Subjects:
Online Access: http://agrt.emu.ee/pdf/2020_1_nutt.pdf
id doaj-fa31768b80104137a36f17af22833cfa
record_format Article
spelling doaj-fa31768b80104137a36f17af22833cfa2020-11-25T03:17:11ZengEstonian Academic Agricultural SocietyAgraarteadus1024-08452228-48932020-06-01311666910.15159/jas.20.01Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forestsNele Nutt0Ardo Kubjas1Minea Kaplinski-Sauk2 Tallinna Tehnikaülikool, Tartu kolledž, inseneriteaduskond Tallinna Tehnikaülikool, Tartu kolledž, inseneriteaduskond Tallinna Tehnikaülikool, Tartu kolledž, inseneriteaduskond The following short communication article presents a method for comparing the species composition of Estonian forests and parks, giving an overview of the data that is currently being gathered and underlining how these two datasets can be compared. Even though both forest and park inventories are carried out throughout the country, to this day there have been no comparative studies on how the species composition of parks and forests differ from each other. This stems from the fact that the park and forest inventories are carried out using different methods. Forest inventories classify most of the trees according to their genera, but also differentiate between the species composition of the forest canopy and sub-canopy layers. The park inventories classify all dendrological plants by their species, also measuring several other individual parameters. The main difference being that park inventories do not differentiate between different canopy layers, rather providing species composition charts that include all the dendrological plants growing in the park. In order to compare the two datasets, it is necessary to transfer the data derived from manor park inventories to match that of the Estonian forest inventory. The first step in implementing the method is to divide the inventory data from parks into the forest canopy and sub-canopy layers. The canopy layer of parks was determined to consist of old trees (>100 years). The age of the trees in parks was modelled after growth charts compiled from the data from Estonian forests, which was then extrapolated to reach 120 years. These growth charts were compared to the breast height diameter of park trees, to determine their age. The canopy layer of parks was then analysed to provide an overview of species composition that corresponds to the same level of generalisation as the forest inventories. The results showed that the species composition of old manor parks differs significantly from most Estonian forests with the majority of the trees in parks being broad-leaved. The proposed method is suitable for comparing forests and parks on a generalised level. http://agrt.emu.ee/pdf/2020_1_nutt.pdf parkforestspecies compositiondendrological inventoryforest habitat
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Nele Nutt
Ardo Kubjas
Minea Kaplinski-Sauk
spellingShingle Nele Nutt
Ardo Kubjas
Minea Kaplinski-Sauk
Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
Agraarteadus
park
forest
species composition
dendrological inventory
forest habitat
author_facet Nele Nutt
Ardo Kubjas
Minea Kaplinski-Sauk
author_sort Nele Nutt
title Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
title_short Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
title_full Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
title_fullStr Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
title_full_unstemmed Short Communication: A method for comparing the tree species composition of Estonian historic manor parks and forests
title_sort short communication: a method for comparing the tree species composition of estonian historic manor parks and forests
publisher Estonian Academic Agricultural Society
series Agraarteadus
issn 1024-0845
2228-4893
publishDate 2020-06-01
description The following short communication article presents a method for comparing the species composition of Estonian forests and parks, giving an overview of the data that is currently being gathered and underlining how these two datasets can be compared. Even though both forest and park inventories are carried out throughout the country, to this day there have been no comparative studies on how the species composition of parks and forests differ from each other. This stems from the fact that the park and forest inventories are carried out using different methods. Forest inventories classify most of the trees according to their genera, but also differentiate between the species composition of the forest canopy and sub-canopy layers. The park inventories classify all dendrological plants by their species, also measuring several other individual parameters. The main difference being that park inventories do not differentiate between different canopy layers, rather providing species composition charts that include all the dendrological plants growing in the park. In order to compare the two datasets, it is necessary to transfer the data derived from manor park inventories to match that of the Estonian forest inventory. The first step in implementing the method is to divide the inventory data from parks into the forest canopy and sub-canopy layers. The canopy layer of parks was determined to consist of old trees (>100 years). The age of the trees in parks was modelled after growth charts compiled from the data from Estonian forests, which was then extrapolated to reach 120 years. These growth charts were compared to the breast height diameter of park trees, to determine their age. The canopy layer of parks was then analysed to provide an overview of species composition that corresponds to the same level of generalisation as the forest inventories. The results showed that the species composition of old manor parks differs significantly from most Estonian forests with the majority of the trees in parks being broad-leaved. The proposed method is suitable for comparing forests and parks on a generalised level.
topic park
forest
species composition
dendrological inventory
forest habitat
url http://agrt.emu.ee/pdf/2020_1_nutt.pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT nelenutt shortcommunicationamethodforcomparingthetreespeciescompositionofestonianhistoricmanorparksandforests
AT ardokubjas shortcommunicationamethodforcomparingthetreespeciescompositionofestonianhistoricmanorparksandforests
AT mineakaplinskisauk shortcommunicationamethodforcomparingthetreespeciescompositionofestonianhistoricmanorparksandforests
_version_ 1724632930070822912