Constructing Indicators of Effectiveness Evaluation for Revitalization Planning of Stilt Houses on Rua dos Navegantes in Coloane, Macao

• Main Authors: Wai Lan Chan, 陳惠蘭
• Other Authors: 曾介宏
• Format: Others
• Language: zh-TW
• Published: 2013
• Online Access: http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/4tcj9x

碩士 === 國立臺北藝術大學 === 藝術行政與管理研究所 === 101 === Rua dos Navegantes, stilt houses in Macanese, are buildings along the coastal area in Coloane, structurally differed from urban architectures. This area is the only area where waterside residential architectures have been well-preserved in Macao, also representing its unique historic and cultural value. In 2012, the Macao government proclaimed the investigation onto revitalization planning for Rua dos Navegantes. Both governments and residents agreed with stilt houses as the distinctive and precious cultural heritage in Macao. However, opinions on the substantial value of stilt houses were controvertibly divided. The division revealed a pending question about unique folkways preserved in process of revitalization, as well as motivated the purpose of this study, exploring the importance of indicators for effectiveness evaluation on related plans. Evaluation has launched in a wide range of research communities, such as policy, management, education, and protected area. Not merely can evaluation apply effectively detection to an ongoing project but it can ascertain the degree of achievement. Additionally, by indicators, effectiveness evaluation devises a way to assess historic and cultural merit. Based on the literature review of evaluation theories, this study referred to the indicators of protected area effectiveness evaluation by Fiona Leverington et al. (2010) moreover, applying four sociological methods, namely, stakeholder analysis, interview, in-depth interview, focus group interview to construct preliminary indicators of effectiveness evaluation for revitalization planning of stilt houses in Coloane, Macao. The frame of indicators of effectiveness evaluation in this study began with collective notions of stakeholders from reports about revitalization planning of stilt houses. Secondly, The frame was revised according to the interviews with the stakeholders involved in the plan. Thirdly, it revised again to integrate with governments’ policy by in-depth interviews with the Minister of Promotion of Cultural and Creative Industries in Macao. Furthermore, it referred to the comments of specialists by the focus group interviews. The study compressed 45 indicators into 10 most important ones ultimately, including 6 phrases – context, planning, input, process, output, and outcome. Taking revitalization planning of Rua dos Navegantes in Macao as example, this study established a model of research on indicators of effectiveness evaluation for revitalization planning by efficiently inspecting the procedure and achievement of plans, and constructing indicators to approach the core value of revitalization. Most of all, this study has proved effectiveness evaluation as a strategic tool of cultural heritage.