The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation
碩士 === 國立臺北大學 === 法律學系一般生組 === 104 === The development of Business Judgment Rule in our country, in contrast to common law, started late, and the concept of this rule is not accepted by all civil judgments. There were a doctrinal dispute of this rule in American law, one considered the rule as the...
Main Authors: | , |
---|---|
Other Authors: | |
Format: | Others |
Language: | zh-TW |
Published: |
2016
|
Online Access: | http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/hntttr |
id |
ndltd-TW-104NTPU0194015 |
---|---|
record_format |
oai_dc |
spelling |
ndltd-TW-104NTPU01940152019-05-15T22:34:18Z http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/hntttr The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation 經營判斷法則之經濟分析- 兼論經營判斷法則於閉鎖性公司之適用 Hsia-Sheng Lin 林夏陞 碩士 國立臺北大學 法律學系一般生組 104 The development of Business Judgment Rule in our country, in contrast to common law, started late, and the concept of this rule is not accepted by all civil judgments. There were a doctrinal dispute of this rule in American law, one considered the rule as the standard of liability, which established a requirement of judicial review and distribution principles of the burden of proof; another seem the rule as an abstention doctrine, which claim that Courts should abstain from reviewing the substantive merits of the directors' conduct unless the plaintiff can carry the very heavy burden of rebutting that presumption. On the other hand, legislations of close company’s chapter in the Taiwan Company Act was adopted last year. It provided a new option to someone who want to set up a Venture Capital or small-capital businesses. But it is a issue that the Business Judgment Rule can apply in the directors’ fiduciary duty cases of close company or not. The minority shareholder in close companies, different from public companies, are vulnerable and could be oppressed by controlling shareholders. It would be unfair that director can protect by Business Judgment Rule when the court review director’s oppression. In this way, this article synthesized the doctrinal dispute and guiding principle of this rule, also discussed the function of this rule in the method of economic analysis. Beside, this article synthesized the Judicial Opinions in Taiwan and commented on its disadvantage. Finally, this article discussed the application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation Hsin-Ti Chang 張心悌 2016 學位論文 ; thesis 163 zh-TW |
collection |
NDLTD |
language |
zh-TW |
format |
Others
|
sources |
NDLTD |
description |
碩士 === 國立臺北大學 === 法律學系一般生組 === 104 === The development of Business Judgment Rule in our country, in contrast to common law, started late, and the concept of this rule is not accepted by all civil judgments. There were a doctrinal dispute of this rule in American law, one considered the rule as the standard of liability, which established a requirement of judicial review and distribution principles of the burden of proof; another seem the rule as an abstention doctrine, which claim that Courts should abstain from reviewing the substantive merits of the directors' conduct unless the plaintiff can carry the very heavy burden of rebutting that presumption.
On the other hand, legislations of close company’s chapter in the Taiwan Company Act was adopted last year. It provided a new option to someone who want to set up a Venture Capital or small-capital businesses. But it is a issue that the Business Judgment Rule can apply in the directors’ fiduciary duty cases of close company or not. The minority shareholder in close companies, different from public companies, are vulnerable and could be oppressed by controlling shareholders. It would be unfair that director can protect by Business Judgment Rule when the court review director’s oppression.
In this way, this article synthesized the doctrinal dispute and guiding principle of this rule, also discussed the function of this rule in the method of economic analysis. Beside, this article synthesized the Judicial Opinions in Taiwan and commented on its disadvantage. Finally, this article discussed the application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation
|
author2 |
Hsin-Ti Chang |
author_facet |
Hsin-Ti Chang Hsia-Sheng Lin 林夏陞 |
author |
Hsia-Sheng Lin 林夏陞 |
spellingShingle |
Hsia-Sheng Lin 林夏陞 The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
author_sort |
Hsia-Sheng Lin |
title |
The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
title_short |
The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
title_full |
The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
title_fullStr |
The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
title_full_unstemmed |
The Economic Analysis of Business Judgment Rule– Also on the Application of Business Judgment Rule in Close Corporation |
title_sort |
economic analysis of business judgment rule– also on the application of business judgment rule in close corporation |
publishDate |
2016 |
url |
http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/handle/hntttr |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT hsiashenglin theeconomicanalysisofbusinessjudgmentrulealsoontheapplicationofbusinessjudgmentruleinclosecorporation AT línxiàshēng theeconomicanalysisofbusinessjudgmentrulealsoontheapplicationofbusinessjudgmentruleinclosecorporation AT hsiashenglin jīngyíngpànduànfǎzézhījīngjìfēnxījiānlùnjīngyíngpànduànfǎzéyúbìsuǒxìnggōngsīzhīshìyòng AT línxiàshēng jīngyíngpànduànfǎzézhījīngjìfēnxījiānlùnjīngyíngpànduànfǎzéyúbìsuǒxìnggōngsīzhīshìyòng AT hsiashenglin economicanalysisofbusinessjudgmentrulealsoontheapplicationofbusinessjudgmentruleinclosecorporation AT línxiàshēng economicanalysisofbusinessjudgmentrulealsoontheapplicationofbusinessjudgmentruleinclosecorporation |
_version_ |
1719132159507169280 |