The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America

In this thesis, two questions are analysed: (1) why have National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) become so widely disseminated among contemporary states? And, (2) what explains the variable institutionalisation of NHRIs once activated? The thesis first traces the diffusion of NHRIs across politic...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Pegram, Thomas Innes
Other Authors: Whitehead, Laurence
Published: University of Oxford 2011
Subjects:
320
Online Access:http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.543624
id ndltd-bl.uk-oai-ethos.bl.uk-543624
record_format oai_dc
spelling ndltd-bl.uk-oai-ethos.bl.uk-5436242015-03-20T04:37:13ZThe global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin AmericaPegram, Thomas InnesWhitehead, Laurence2011In this thesis, two questions are analysed: (1) why have National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) become so widely disseminated among contemporary states? And, (2) what explains the variable institutionalisation of NHRIs once activated? The thesis first traces the diffusion of NHRIs across political regimes in general, with particular attention to unstable democratic regimes. It argues that NHRI creation can be attributed to three principal diffusion mechanisms: coercion, acculturation, and persuasion. These three explanatory models, however, lack precision. Linking each mechanism to recent processes of diffusion in Latin America, the analysis identifies how the diffusion of an Iberian variant to the generic NHRI category - the Defensorfa del Pueblo - corresponds to three intermediate categories: compulsion, material inducement and framing of ideas. The initial political circumstance of Defensoria creation in Latin America, in turn, has significant implications for their institutionalisation. A domestic level of analysis is necessary to explain the institutionalisation of Defensorias operating in the democratic regimes of Latin America. The standard explanation correlates performance with structural form. While this thesis recognises the development of formal design principles is important in explaining institutionalisation, it adds a major qualification. It shows that the informal dimension of Defensorias' relations with organised state and social actors and rules of access across accountability arenas is often decisive. A typological framework is generated to assess the impact of these two dimensions on Defensorias when formal rules are enforced in a variable manner and tend to lack stability over time. This comparative analysis highlights the accountability gap which these institutions attempt, importantly, to address. By explaining how Defensorias actually work, including when and why they matter, this thesis goes beyond narrow institutionalism as suggested by the political accountability literature.320Human rights : International cooperation : Politics and government : Latin AmericaUniversity of Oxfordhttp://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.543624http://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:2b5e171e-10b0-4a55-a5ca-dcdee61750bfElectronic Thesis or Dissertation
collection NDLTD
sources NDLTD
topic 320
Human rights : International cooperation : Politics and government : Latin America
spellingShingle 320
Human rights : International cooperation : Politics and government : Latin America
Pegram, Thomas Innes
The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
description In this thesis, two questions are analysed: (1) why have National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) become so widely disseminated among contemporary states? And, (2) what explains the variable institutionalisation of NHRIs once activated? The thesis first traces the diffusion of NHRIs across political regimes in general, with particular attention to unstable democratic regimes. It argues that NHRI creation can be attributed to three principal diffusion mechanisms: coercion, acculturation, and persuasion. These three explanatory models, however, lack precision. Linking each mechanism to recent processes of diffusion in Latin America, the analysis identifies how the diffusion of an Iberian variant to the generic NHRI category - the Defensorfa del Pueblo - corresponds to three intermediate categories: compulsion, material inducement and framing of ideas. The initial political circumstance of Defensoria creation in Latin America, in turn, has significant implications for their institutionalisation. A domestic level of analysis is necessary to explain the institutionalisation of Defensorias operating in the democratic regimes of Latin America. The standard explanation correlates performance with structural form. While this thesis recognises the development of formal design principles is important in explaining institutionalisation, it adds a major qualification. It shows that the informal dimension of Defensorias' relations with organised state and social actors and rules of access across accountability arenas is often decisive. A typological framework is generated to assess the impact of these two dimensions on Defensorias when formal rules are enforced in a variable manner and tend to lack stability over time. This comparative analysis highlights the accountability gap which these institutions attempt, importantly, to address. By explaining how Defensorias actually work, including when and why they matter, this thesis goes beyond narrow institutionalism as suggested by the political accountability literature.
author2 Whitehead, Laurence
author_facet Whitehead, Laurence
Pegram, Thomas Innes
author Pegram, Thomas Innes
author_sort Pegram, Thomas Innes
title The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
title_short The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
title_full The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
title_fullStr The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
title_full_unstemmed The global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in Latin America
title_sort global diffusion of national human rights institutions and their political impact in latin america
publisher University of Oxford
publishDate 2011
url http://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.543624
work_keys_str_mv AT pegramthomasinnes theglobaldiffusionofnationalhumanrightsinstitutionsandtheirpoliticalimpactinlatinamerica
AT pegramthomasinnes globaldiffusionofnationalhumanrightsinstitutionsandtheirpoliticalimpactinlatinamerica
_version_ 1716785740551028736