Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People

As agents, social robots are expected to increase opportunities for dialogue with the elderly. However, it is difficult to sustain a dialogue with an elderly user because speech recognition frequently fails during the dialogue. Here, to overcome this problem, regardless of speech recognition failure...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Takamasa Iio, Yuichiro Yoshikawa, Mariko Chiba, Taichi Asami, Yoshinori Isoda, Hiroshi Ishiguro
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-02-01
Series:Applied Sciences
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/10/4/1522
id doaj-02948102ab364dc3ba326cf9f0d7d610
record_format Article
spelling doaj-02948102ab364dc3ba326cf9f0d7d6102020-11-25T02:16:18ZengMDPI AGApplied Sciences2076-34172020-02-01104152210.3390/app10041522app10041522Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly PeopleTakamasa Iio0Yuichiro Yoshikawa1Mariko Chiba2Taichi Asami3Yoshinori Isoda4Hiroshi Ishiguro5Faculty of Engineering, Information and Systems, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba 305-8573, JapanGraduate School of Engineering Science, Osaka University, Toyonaka 560-0043, JapanNTT DOCOMO, Inc., Tokyo 100-6150, JapanNTT DOCOMO, Inc., Tokyo 100-6150, JapanNTT DOCOMO, Inc., Tokyo 100-6150, JapanGraduate School of Engineering Science, Osaka University, Toyonaka 560-0043, JapanAs agents, social robots are expected to increase opportunities for dialogue with the elderly. However, it is difficult to sustain a dialogue with an elderly user because speech recognition frequently fails during the dialogue. Here, to overcome this problem, regardless of speech recognition failure, we developed a question−answer−response dialogue model. In this model, a robot took initiative in the dialogue by asking the user various questions. Moreover, to improve user experience during dialogue, we extended the model such that two robots could participate in the dialogue. Implementing these features, we conducted a field trial in a nursing home to evaluate the twin-robot dialogue system. The average word error rate of speech recognition was 0.778. Despite the frequently high number of errors, participants talked for 14 min in a dialogue with two robots and felt slightly strange during the dialogue. Although we found no significant difference between a dialogue with one robot and that with two robots, the effect size of the difference in the dialogue time with one robot and that with two robots was medium (Cohen’s d = −0.519). The results suggested that the presence of two robots might likely encourage elderly people to sustain the talk. Our results will contribute to the design of social robots to engage in dialogues with the elderly.https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/10/4/1522dialogue systemelderly peopletwo robots
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Takamasa Iio
Yuichiro Yoshikawa
Mariko Chiba
Taichi Asami
Yoshinori Isoda
Hiroshi Ishiguro
spellingShingle Takamasa Iio
Yuichiro Yoshikawa
Mariko Chiba
Taichi Asami
Yoshinori Isoda
Hiroshi Ishiguro
Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
Applied Sciences
dialogue system
elderly people
two robots
author_facet Takamasa Iio
Yuichiro Yoshikawa
Mariko Chiba
Taichi Asami
Yoshinori Isoda
Hiroshi Ishiguro
author_sort Takamasa Iio
title Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
title_short Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
title_full Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
title_fullStr Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
title_full_unstemmed Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People
title_sort twin-robot dialogue system with robustness against speech recognition failure in human-robot dialogue with elderly people
publisher MDPI AG
series Applied Sciences
issn 2076-3417
publishDate 2020-02-01
description As agents, social robots are expected to increase opportunities for dialogue with the elderly. However, it is difficult to sustain a dialogue with an elderly user because speech recognition frequently fails during the dialogue. Here, to overcome this problem, regardless of speech recognition failure, we developed a question−answer−response dialogue model. In this model, a robot took initiative in the dialogue by asking the user various questions. Moreover, to improve user experience during dialogue, we extended the model such that two robots could participate in the dialogue. Implementing these features, we conducted a field trial in a nursing home to evaluate the twin-robot dialogue system. The average word error rate of speech recognition was 0.778. Despite the frequently high number of errors, participants talked for 14 min in a dialogue with two robots and felt slightly strange during the dialogue. Although we found no significant difference between a dialogue with one robot and that with two robots, the effect size of the difference in the dialogue time with one robot and that with two robots was medium (Cohen’s d = −0.519). The results suggested that the presence of two robots might likely encourage elderly people to sustain the talk. Our results will contribute to the design of social robots to engage in dialogues with the elderly.
topic dialogue system
elderly people
two robots
url https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/10/4/1522
work_keys_str_mv AT takamasaiio twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
AT yuichiroyoshikawa twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
AT marikochiba twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
AT taichiasami twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
AT yoshinoriisoda twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
AT hiroshiishiguro twinrobotdialoguesystemwithrobustnessagainstspeechrecognitionfailureinhumanrobotdialoguewithelderlypeople
_version_ 1724891339657576448